NSCAA
Men's All-South
| Name | Position | School | Year |
| Brian Ackley | M | Athens Drive | 2004 |
| Nick Acosta | M | Swansboro | 2000 |
| Caleb Alexander | F | T.C. Roberson | 2004 |
| Eduardo Alvarez | F | Greensboro Day | 2009 |
| Cody Arnoux | F | New Hanover | 2005 |
| Bakty Barber | Sanderson | 1979 | |
| Harry Barber | Sanderson | 1980, 1981 | |
| Renato Barbosa | M | East Mecklenburg | 2004 |
| Tyler Bathurst | M | East Forsyth | 2005 |
| Shon Beachum | F | Sanderson | 1990, 1991, 1992 |
| TJ Beaulieu | F | Apex | 2006 |
| Stephen Bickford | F | Greenhope | 2003, 2004 |
| David Boole | F | Millbrook | 2002 |
| John Bradford | D | Mount Tabor | 1997 |
| Justin Branch | F | Apex | 2000 |
| Clark Brisson | F | Sanderson | 1984, 1985, 1986 |
| Matt Brown | F | Olympic | 2007 |
| John Buffaloe | Sanderson | 1983 | |
| Daniel Butner | M | Salisbury | 2001 |
| Chris Campbell | F | Greensboro Day | 2009 |
| D.C. Carrol | F | White Oak | 1998 |
| Carlos Cipriano | F | Leesville Road | 2007 |
| Will Clark | F | Myers Park | 2001 |
| Renato Corte | K | Asheville | 2005 |
| Hugh Cronin | M | Mount Tabor | 2002, 2003 |
| McNeil Cronin | M | Mount Tabor | 1999 |
| Sam Cronin | M | Mount Tabor | 2003, 2004 |
| Brad Darby | D | Greenhope | 2002 |
| Adam Davis | M | New Bern | 2000 |
| Jamie DeGraw | D | Greensboro Day | 1998 |
| Bryan Deutsch | F | Northwest Guilford | 1999 |
| Tommy Drake | M | Chapel Hill | 2006 |
| Thomas Driver | M | Grimsley | 2007 |
| Chris Dulaney | F | West Forsyth | 1998 |
| Mark Ellington | M | Swansboro | 2001 |
| Patrick Farrell | M | Grimsley | 2001, 2002 |
| Matt Foxx | F | Lake Norman | 2007 |
| Robert Franklin | F | T.C. Roberson | 2006 |
| Ray Fumo | M | Parkwood | 2000 |
| Michael Gell | M | Riverside | 1998 |
| Guisseppe Gentile | F | Ardrey Kell | 2009 |
| Scott Goodwin | K | Broughton | 2008 |
| Willie Griffin | F | Broughton | 2005 |
| Kye Grooms | M | AC Reynolds | 2007 |
| Juan Guzman | M | Latin | 2004, 2005 |
| Sean Haglund | F | North Raleigh Christian | 2006, 2007 |
| Zach Haines | F | Southwest Guilford | 2003 |
| Coleman Hall | M | Asheville | 2001 |
| Ryan Hanley | M | St. Stephens | 1999 |
| Brandon Haynes | F | Broughton | 2008 |
| Mike Hemphill | F | T.C. Roberson | 1997 |
| William Hesmer | K | Hunt | 1999 |
| Wilson Hood | F | AC Reynolds | 2006 |
| Justin Hughes | K | Wakefield | 2002 |
| Clint Irwin | K | Charlotte Christian | 2006 |
| Jimmy Johnson | F | Jacksonville | 2008, 2009 |
| Ryan Johnson | M | Charlotte Country Day | 2004 |
| Soren Johnson | K | Watauga | 1998 |
| Brett King | D | Ashley | 2006 |
| Drew Kraly | F | New Hanover | 2001 |
| Chris Kyryliuk | M | Charlotte Catholic | 2009 |
| J.T. LaBruyere | M | T.C. Roberson | 2002, 2003 |
| Gabe Latigue | M | Panther Creek | 2008 |
| Mark Linnville | D | NCSSM | 2008 |
| Phillip Long | D | Hunt | 2001 |
| Rober Lovejoy | F | Page | 2009 |
| Will Mackvick | K | Broughton | 2006 |
| Eric Martinez | D | Providence Day | 2008 |
| Alex Maslow | K | Catholic | 2000 |
| Tim Masters | F | Charlotte Latin | 2003, 2004 |
| Robert May | F | T.C. Roberson | 2008 |
| Will Mayhew | M | JM Robinson | 2008 |
| Sean McGinty | F | East Mecklenburg | 1998, 1999 |
| Will McGinnis | F | Charlotte Latin | 2009 |
| Logan Meadows | F | Asheville | 2000 |
| Ryan Metts | M | Wakefield | 2009 |
| Stephen Miller | F | Charlotte Latin | 2005 |
| David Moore | M | Leesville Road | 1997 |
| Justin Moose | F | Statesville | 2001 |
| Senyonju Mukungosr | D | Jordan | 2009 |
| Patrick Murphy | F | Watauga | 1999 |
| Antonio Myers | F | Christ School | 2000 |
| Ben Newnam | M | East Forsyth | 2007, 2008 |
| Caleb Norkus | F | Sanderson | 1996 |
| Jacob Pace | F | Salisbury | 1999 |
| Cliff Patterson | M | Jacksonville | 1997 |
| Chase Perfect | M | Jordan | 2002 |
| Grant Porter | M | Providence Day | 1997, 1998, 1999 |
| Brad Ramsey | F | RJ Reynolds | 2003, 2004 |
| Jorge Redmond | F | T.C. Roberson | 1995 |
| Todd Renner | Sanderson | 1984 | |
| Zach Robinson | D | North Mecklenburg | 2001 |
| J.R. Rodgers | D | Leesville Road | 2000 |
| Chipper Root | F | Chapel Hill | 2009 |
| Matt Rose | M | Wesleyan Academy | 2008 |
| Justin Schatz | F | East Wake | 1997 |
| Zack Schilawski | M | Cary | 2003, 2004, 2005 |
| Will Shull | M | Shelby | 2006 |
| Calvin Simon | F | New Hanover | 2002 |
| Blake Smith | M | East Chapel Hill | 2001 |
| Donnie Smith | M | Charlotte Catholic | 2008 |
| Indy Smith | M | Asheville | 2005 |
| Ryan Solle | F | Lee County | 2001 |
| Magnus Sorenson | M | Cary | 2007 |
| Tyler Spence | D | Grimsley | 1997 |
| Lee Superville | F | Enloe | 2002 |
| Andy Tabor | F | Leesville Road | 1999 |
| David Testo | F | T.C. Roberson | 1998 |
| Brandon Thomas | F | Providence | 2000 |
| Kenzo Tochiki | M | Myers Park | 1998 |
| Ross Tomaselli | M | New Hanover | 2009 |
| Watt Williams | M | Broughton | 2006, 2007 |
| Jay Wyatt | F | Providence | 2003 |
| Justin Wyatt | F | Sanderson | 2004, 2005 |
| Noz Yamauchi | M | East Chapel Hill | 1997 |